WhatsApp us

Proof-based real analysis, online

Real analysis tutor online: learn to write the proofs, with Ajay Vatsyayan

Real analysis is the course where calculus has to be proved, and many students find the jump from computing to proving the hardest step of their degree. Ajay Vatsyayan teaches it one to one online: how to read a definition, how to plan an epsilon argument in scratch work, and how to write a proof a grader accepts, following your own course notes.

Epsilon-N proofsEpsilon-deltaSupremum and completenessContinuityRiemann integralUniform convergence
Ajay Vatsyayan, senior maths tutor at Maths Bodhi, Gurugram

1:1

Online sessions

Proofs

Read, planned and written with you

Your notes

Definitions as your lecturer states them

I understand the lecture while it's happening, but faced with a blank page and 'prove that aₙ → 3' I don't know how to start.

My proofs get marked down for 'logic' and I can't see what's wrong with them.

I passed calculus easily, and now supremum, Cauchy sequences and uniform convergence feel like a different subject.

Why it feels hard

Why the first analysis course feels like a different subject

In calculus you were asked to find things: a derivative, an integral, a sum. In analysis you are asked to show that things are true, using only definitions and results already proved. Imperial College London describes university mathematics as being 'more about problem solving and rigorous proof than about tackling routine exercises and calculations', and real analysis is where most students feel that change first.

Strong calculus students are often surprised to struggle. The difficulty is rarely the ideas, which are about limits and continuity they already know. It is the language: quantifiers in a fixed order, inequalities instead of equations, and arguments where each line must follow from the one before. That language can be taught directly, and that is what sessions focus on.

  • Reading 'for every ε > 0 there exists N' and not seeing that N is allowed to depend on ε, but ε is not allowed to depend on n.
  • Writing the scratch work (working backwards from what you want) as if it were the proof.
  • Negating a definition wrongly, so a proof by contradiction proves nothing.
  • Using a picture or a calculus fact that the course has not yet proved.
  • Stopping once an inequality looks plausible instead of finishing the chain to < ε.

Course mapping

Where real analysis sits in your degree

In UK mathematics degrees analysis usually starts in the first year. Imperial's first-year mathematics programme includes Analysis I, and the University of Manchester lists Real Analysis (MATH11112) and Mathematical Foundations & Analysis (MATH11121) among its Year 1 units for mathematics and statistics.

In the US, real analysis is usually an upper-level course taken after the calculus sequence and linear algebra, often after an introduction to proofs course. Titles and numbers vary between universities, so send us your course page and syllabus. In India, real analysis is a core part of B.Sc. and M.Sc. mathematics. Master's students who need the analysis behind a course or project can book sessions on just those ideas.

Most first courses follow a similar path: the real numbers and completeness, sequences, series, limits and continuity, differentiation, the Riemann integral, then sequences and series of functions. A second course may move into metric spaces or measure theory; tell us which topics your syllabus includes.

Topic map

Real analysis, topic by topic: what you must be able to prove

This is the map Ajay uses to plan a course. The third column is the kind of question that appears on problem sheets and finals; the fourth is where we most often see marks disappear in a student's written proof.

A first course in real analysis
TopicWhat you must be able to proveTypical questionWhere marks go
Real numbers and completenessProperties of supremum and infimum; the Archimedean propertyFind sup and inf of a set and prove they are correctShowing an upper bound but not that it is the least one
Convergence of sequencesaₙ → L from the ε-N definitionProve (3n + 1)/(n + 2) → 3Choosing N that depends on n
Limit laws and the squeeze theoremSum, product and quotient of convergent sequencesProve the product of convergent sequences convergesNot bounding one factor first
Monotone sequences and Bolzano–WeierstrassBounded monotone sequences converge; bounded sequences have convergent subsequencesShow a recursively defined sequence converges and find its limitAssuming the limit exists before proving it
Cauchy sequencesCauchy is equivalent to convergent in ℝProve a sequence is Cauchy without knowing its limitConfusing |aₙ₊₁ − aₙ| → 0 with the Cauchy condition
SeriesComparison, ratio and alternating series tests from the definitionsProve Σ 1/n diverges; decide absolute or conditional convergenceCiting a test whose hypotheses are not checked
Limits of functions and continuityε-δ limits; sequential characterisationProve x² − x → 6 as x → 3Letting δ depend on x
Properties of continuous functionsIntermediate value and extreme value theoremsShow a polynomial has a root in an intervalUsing the theorem on a set that is not closed and bounded
Uniform continuityUniform versus pointwise continuity; continuous on [a, b] implies uniformShow 1/x is not uniformly continuous on (0, 1)Negating the definition in the wrong order
DifferentiationRolle's theorem, the mean value theorem, Taylor's theorem with remainderUse the MVT to prove an inequality such as |sin a − sin b| ≤ |a − b|Forgetting to state continuity and differentiability conditions
Riemann integralUpper and lower sums; integrability of continuous functions; the fundamental theoremShow a step function is integrable using partitionsUsing antiderivatives before the theorem allows it
Sequences and series of functionsPointwise versus uniform convergence; what uniform convergence preservesDecide whether fₙ converges uniformly on a given setComputing the pointwise limit but not the supremum of the error

Writing proofs

How an analysis proof is built: scratch work first, proof second

Almost every epsilon proof is written in two passes, and most marking problems come from mixing them up. The first pass is private: you start from the inequality you want and work backwards to discover how large N, or how small δ, must be. The second pass is the proof itself, written forwards: given ε, here is N; take any n beyond it; here is the chain of inequalities ending in ε.

Ajay teaches the two passes as separate skills. Students keep a scratch column and a proof column on the shared screen, and in the early weeks every proof is checked line by line for three things: is every symbol introduced before it is used, are the quantifiers in the order the definition demands, and does each inequality follow from something already stated.

1. State the goal

Write out the definition you must satisfy with the actual sequence or function substituted in.

2. Scratch work

Simplify |aₙ − L| or |f(x) − L|, bound the awkward factor, and find the condition on n or δ.

3. Write it forwards

Let ε > 0. Choose N (or δ). Suppose n ≥ N (or 0 < |x − a| < δ). Then a chain of inequalities ending below ε.

4. Conclude

Say which definition is now satisfied. Graders look for that final sentence.

Worked examples

Three complete proofs in the style of a first analysis course

These are original problems. The steps are written as a final proof, with the scratch work summarised where it decides the choice of N or δ.

An ε-N proof for a sequence

Prove from the definition that aₙ = (3n + 1)/(n + 2) converges to 3.

  1. Scratch work: |aₙ − 3| = |3n + 1 − 3(n + 2)|/(n + 2) = 5/(n + 2), and 5/(n + 2) < 5/n, so it is enough to make 5/n < ε, that is n > 5/ε.
  2. Proof. Let ε > 0. By the Archimedean property, choose a natural number N with N > 5/ε.
  3. Let n ≥ N. Then |aₙ − 3| = 5/(n + 2) < 5/n ≤ 5/N < ε.
  4. Since ε > 0 was arbitrary, aₙ → 3 by the definition of convergence.

Answer: Proved, with N any natural number greater than 5/ε (for ε = 0.1, N = 51 works).

N depends only on ε. Any natural N greater than 5/ε − 2 also works; the cruder bound 5/n just makes the choice easier. What matters is that N is fixed before n is chosen.

An ε-δ proof for a limit of a function

Prove that the limit of f(x) = x² − x as x → 3 is 6.

  1. Scratch work: |f(x) − 6| = |x² − x − 6| = |x − 3|·|x + 2|. The factor |x + 2| must be controlled. If |x − 3| < 1 then 2 < x < 4, so 4 < x + 2 < 6 and |x + 2| < 6.
  2. Proof. Let ε > 0 and put δ = min(1, ε/6). Then δ > 0.
  3. Suppose 0 < |x − 3| < δ. Since δ ≤ 1, we have |x − 3| < 1, so |x + 2| < 6.
  4. Then |f(x) − 6| = |x − 3|·|x + 2| < δ·6 ≤ (ε/6)·6 = ε.
  5. So for every ε > 0 there is δ > 0 with |f(x) − 6| < ε whenever 0 < |x − 3| < δ, which is the definition of the limit being 6.

Answer: Proved, with δ = min(1, ε/6).

The min is the key idea: the first restriction (δ ≤ 1) bounds |x + 2|; the second makes the product small.

Uniform convergence of a sequence of functions

Let fₙ(x) = x/(1 + nx²) for x in ℝ. Show that fₙ → 0 uniformly on ℝ.

  1. Pointwise limit: for each fixed x, fₙ(x) → 0 as n → ∞ (if x = 0 every term is 0; otherwise the denominator grows like nx²).
  2. Uniform bound: by the AM-GM inequality, 1 + nx² ≥ 2√n·|x|. So for x ≠ 0, |fₙ(x)| = |x|/(1 + nx²) ≤ |x|/(2√n·|x|) = 1/(2√n), and the bound also holds at x = 0.
  3. So sup over x in ℝ of |fₙ(x) − 0| ≤ 1/(2√n), with equality at x = 1/√n, where fₙ = (1/√n)/2.
  4. Let ε > 0 and choose N with N > 1/(4ε²). For n ≥ N, 1/(2√n) ≤ 1/(2√N) < ε, so |fₙ(x)| < ε for every x at once.
  5. That is the definition of uniform convergence to 0 on ℝ.

Answer: fₙ → 0 uniformly on ℝ, since sup |fₙ| = 1/(2√n) → 0.

Contrast gₙ(x) = xⁿ on [0, 1]: its pointwise limit jumps from 0 to 1 at x = 1, so the convergence cannot be uniform, because a uniform limit of continuous functions is continuous.

How sessions work

How we teach real analysis online

Sessions are online with handwritten proofs on a shared screen, at a time agreed by your time zone. Because analysis depends on the exact wording of definitions, we use your lecturer's versions, not a textbook's.

1. Before the first session

Send your lecture notes or textbook (Abbott, Bartle and Sherbert or your own department's notes), the current problem sheet, a marked piece of work with the grader's comments, and exam dates.

2. Diagnostic

You talk through two short proofs aloud. Hearing how you read the definition tells Ajay whether to start with logic and quantifiers or go straight to the course material.

3. Weekly pattern

One definition or theorem in depth, a model proof built from scratch work, then a proof you write while Ajay comments line by line.

4. Exam preparation

A list of definitions and theorems you must state exactly, the standard proofs your course expects you to reproduce, and timed past papers.

5. After the exam

We go through the marked script and plan for the next course, whether that is a second analysis course, metric spaces or complex analysis.

First month

Our usual first month with a new analysis student

This is our usual approach for a student who joins a few weeks into the term. It is a typical plan, not a promise, and we change it to match your syllabus.

Typical first four weeks
WeekFocusBy the end you can
1Logic, quantifiers and negation; supremum and infimumNegate any definition correctly and prove a number is a supremum
2ε-N proofs for sequences, including limit lawsWrite a complete convergence proof without notes
3Monotone convergence, subsequences and Cauchy sequencesProve a recursive sequence converges and find its limit
4Series and the first ε-δ limitsProve convergence tests and write a clean ε-δ proof using a min for δ

Fit

Who this suits, and when another option is better

It suits students in a first or second real analysis course who are willing to attempt proofs between sessions and want feedback on how they write them, and students in an introduction to proofs course who want to be ready before analysis begins. Ajay holds an M.Tech and has 14+ years teaching maths, and he teaches real analysis online to students in India and abroad.

It does not suit anyone who wants proofs written for submission. Students who only need calculus methods, not proofs, will be better served by our calculus or engineering mathematics pages. Home tuition is available in Gurgaon (Gurugram). Students elsewhere in India and abroad learn with us online.

Academic integrity

We teach proof-writing; we never write your proofs for credit

Proof-based problem sheets are often graded, so this matters more in analysis than anywhere else. We explain definitions and theorems, work through parallel problems and give detailed feedback on proofs you have written yourself. We do not write graded proofs or assignments, take online tests or exams in your place, or write dissertations or other assessed work. If a question is from a graded sheet, Ajay teaches the technique on a different example and you write your own proof.

Study guides

Free guides for this course

Worked examples and exam advice from the Maths Bodhi team, topic by topic.

FAQ

Questions students ask about real analysis tutoring

How do I start a real analysis proof?

Write down the definition you need to satisfy with your sequence or function substituted in, then do scratch work backwards to find N or δ. The proof is then written forwards.

Is real analysis harder than calculus?

It is harder in a different way. The ideas are familiar from calculus, but you must prove every step, and most students need a few weeks to get used to that.

Can you teach epsilon-delta proofs from the beginning?

Yes. We start with quantifiers and negation, then ε-N proofs for sequences, then ε-δ for functions.

Which textbook do you use?

Yours. Send your lecture notes or the book your course follows, and we use your lecturer's definitions.

I'm in an intro to proofs course now. Should I start before analysis?

Many students find it helps. A few sessions on logic, induction and writing short proofs make the first weeks of analysis much easier.

Do you teach metric spaces or a second analysis course?

Share the syllabus. Ajay teaches real analysis, and we will tell you honestly which topics in a later course he covers.

How many sessions a week do students take?

Usually one or two through the term, so there is time to attempt proofs between sessions. More are common just before exams.

Do you work with students outside India?

Yes. Sessions are online, and times are agreed by your time zone when you enquire.

Will you write my problem sheet proofs?

No. We teach the method on parallel examples and review proofs you have written yourself.

Next step

Send us one proof you are stuck on

Share your university, course name, lecture notes or textbook, your time zone and a proof you could not finish. Maths Bodhi will confirm whether Ajay is the right fit and suggest session times.